Very rude editor. Sent an uprofessional, nasty rejection via email. I asked for review comments, but he would not send them to me. I will not sumbit to this journal until this editor is out.


I also got an email rejection consisting of a few sentences from the editor. He did not send reviewer comments so I requested them. He did not respond. Very frustrating.


I had a similar experience. The editor informed me that the reviewers suggested and R & R, but he disagreed. I was not sent their comments. I did not find the editor to be rude, but the processes was not helpful.